How to Report Double Brokering: Detect and Prevent Freight Scams

Knowing how to report double brokering in the freight industry is becoming increasingly more important. Freight fraud is on the rise, and everyone from brokers to shippers and carriers are being negatively impacted. 

Key Takeaways

• Addressing double brokering requires actions such as contacting the primary broker, documenting all communications, and filing complaints with regulatory authorities like the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA)
• To identify this deceptive practice, look for inconsistencies in shipping documents, unexplained delays, and aggressive requests for early, up-front payments.
• Help prevent double brokering by vetting brokers, setting clear communication expectations, and maintaining secure internal controls at your company.

In this guide, I’ll discuss the tools and knowledge needed to not only detect and prevent double brokering, but report it to the proper authorities. 

How to Detect and Prevent Double Brokering

Before you can report double brokering, you’ll need to know to identify a few tell-tale signs of the practice.

One of the biggest red flags for double brokerage is when a broker posts a suspiciously high freight rate or makes no attempt to haggle for a better price. For carriers, this will probably be your earliest indicator of the possibility that you’re dealing with a double broker. Shippers, on the other hand, aren’t likely to see this issue as immediately. 

Either way, if you suspect double brokering is occurring in any of your freight transactions, follow these steps to confirm your suspicions and prevent future occurrences of this fraudulent practice. 

1. Thorough Documentation Review: Scrutinize all documentation related to the shipment, including bills of lading (BoLs), contracts, and communication records. Inconsistencies may indicate third-party involvement. 
2. Direct Communication With Carriers: Confirm details such as pick-up and delivery schedules directly with the carrier(s) to ensure alignment with the information provided by the broker.
3. Check for Multiple Brokers on the Same Load: Use load-tracking systems and online platforms to check if multiple brokers are listed for the same load. 
4. Verify Carrier Information: This includes their motor carrier number (MC#), insurance, and operating authority. 
5. Monitor for Last-Minute Changes: Keep an eye out for last-minute changes in the broker's communication regarding the carrier, or any unexpected alterations to the transportation plan. 
6. Use Load Tracking Technology: Leverage load tracking technology to monitor the progress of shipments in real-time. Sudden changes in carriers or routes not communicated by the broker may indicate fraudulent activity. 
7. Establish Clear Communication Expectations: Request detailed information about the carriers involved and ensure that any changes are promptly communicated.
8. Review Online Reviews and Ratings: Negative reviews or reports of unethical practices by the brokerage in question may serve as a warning.
9. Network and Industry Information: Industry information from sites such as FreightWaves can help identify double brokers. .
10. Internal Audits and Controls: This may involve cross-referencing records and conducting periodic reviews of broker performance.
11. Educate Staff and Partners: Encourage a culture of transparency and prompt reporting of any suspicious activities.

By incorporating these practices into your due diligence process, you can enhance your ability to detect and prevent double brokering. Doing so protects your shipments and maintains the integrity of your business operations.

How to Report Double Brokerage 

Reporting double brokering is a crucial step in maintaining the integrity of the transportation industry and safeguarding against fraudulent practices. If you suspect or have evidence of double brokering, follow these steps to effectively report the incident:

1. Gather Evidence: Collect and organize the documentation you gathered during the verification process.  Note any discrepancies or irregularities that suggest the involvement of multiple brokers.
2. Identify the Parties Involved: Clearly identify the brokers, carriers, and any other parties involved in the incident. Record contact information and details about their operations.
3. Contact the Primary Broker: Reach out to the broker you originally contracted with and express your concerns. Provide them with the evidence you have gathered and seek clarification on any potential double brokering activities.
4. Document Communication: Keep a detailed record of all communication with the primary broker. Note their responses, any commitments made, and the steps they intend to take to address the issue.
5. Use Industry Platforms: If the incident involves online load boards or platforms, take advantage of their reporting mechanisms. Many platforms have these features in place to alert administrators about suspicious activities.
6. Contact Regulatory Authorities: Reach out to relevant regulatory authorities, such as the FMCSA or the U.S. Department of Transportation's Office of Inspector General (OIG) Hotline. Provide them with a detailed report of the double brokering incident and any supporting evidence.
7. File a Complaint: File a formal complaint with the FMCSA against the broker(s) involved. 
8. Report to Industry Associations: These groups may have mechanisms in place to address such issues, and can contribute to raising awareness within the industry.
9. Use Whistleblower Programs: Some regulatory bodies have these programs in place to encourage reporting of fraudulent activities. 
10. Seek Legal Advice: An attorney with expertise in transportation law can guide you on the best course of action if civil recourse is an option.
11. Share Information with Peers: Inform other shippers and carriers about the incident to raise awareness and prevent them from falling victim to the same activities.

Remember, reporting double brokering is not only in your best interest, but also contributes to the integrity and trustworthiness of the logistics industry as a whole. By taking these steps, you play a part in promoting ethical practices and protecting the interests of all stakeholders involved in a shipment. 

Related: What is Double Brokering?

Avoid Double Brokering With USA Truckload Shipping

USA Truckload Shipping stands ready to provide transparent and reliable freight services, ensuring you never have to worry about issues like double brokering. We have a network of reliable carriers that can transport your cargo safely and quickly. 

With our Global Vision tracking software, you’ll have full visibility of your shipment and complete transparency regarding the transportation of your freight.

Trust us with all your freight shipment needs, including:

• Professional logistics consultations
• Full truckload shipping
• Drayage services
• And more

Whether you’re moving a single truckload or managing an entire freight network, we are equipped to deliver results you can rely on. If you’re ready to use our services, fill out your request for proposal. Our team is also available at (866) 353-7178 if you have any questions or concerns.